Webinar: Value Enhancement on Civil Engineering Schemes
Richard Moorcroft, Group Operations and Engineering Director, and Siobhan Murphy, Technical Director, explored the challenges in unlocking long-term value across the lifecycle of a complex civil engineering scheme, sharing the lessons and tips they felt could support future schemes.
Eastern Green, Coventry, A45 HIF Works
Background
- The A45 is a strategic highway linking Coventry & Birmingham
- Dual carriageway, national Speed limit route
- Urban environment with significant constraints
- Traffic flows necessitated a grade separated junction for primary access
Scheme Involves
- C. 2km of new highway with associated drainage
- Three new roundabouts, slip roads with the A45
- A new bridge over the A45
- 4 no. culverted watercourse crossings
- Utility diversions
- New service supplies to serve future phases
Constraints
- Areas of Flood Zone 2 and 3 – Pickford Brook
- Extensive utilities within the A45 corridor
- Two no. extra high voltage over head lines
- Existing vegetation
- Great Crested Newts
- Badgers
- Archaeological finds
- Prevailing site levels
Roles & Responsibilities
Brookbanks
- Lead designer in pre contract phase
- Commercial & Project Management
- Contract administrator
- Employers Agent
- Principal Designer (CDM)
Breheny
- Principal Contractor
- Lead designer during construction phase
Strategic Oversight and Collaborative Design: Brookbanks’ Role in Pre-Construction and Project Management
The pre-construction phase of the project was led by Brookbanks, who played a central role in both civil design and overall project management. Supported by funding from Homes England through the Housing Infrastructure Fund (HIF), and in partnership with Coventry City Council, the project required careful coordination and transparent communication to maintain stakeholder confidence.
Homes England received regular updates on progress and forward planning, ensuring continued trust in the appropriate use of funds. Following a judicial review of the planning consent, project milestones were renegotiated and agreed upon with Homes England, resulting in a revised but realistic programme. Site visits by Homes England during the construction phase further reinforced accountability and transparency.
The design process was a collaborative effort involving Brookbanks as the lead for civil design, Pell Frischmann for bridge, geotechnical, and culvert design, and Coventry City Council for street lighting. Weekly progress meetings ensured alignment across all teams, and the design brief—covering parameters such as bridge type, span, width, and materials—was agreed early in the process to guide technical development.
Departures from standard design practices were necessary due to site-specific constraints, such as the proximity of junctions to existing access points. These deviations were discussed and approved early on with Coventry City Council, ensuring compliance and smooth progression through the planning and design stages.
Commercial Process
Tendering the Works:
- Tendered in collaboration with Coventry City Council – OJEU process(public procurement rules)
- Design & Construct Contract to maximise risk / reward opportunities
- Breheny granted preferred bidder status to permit start of ECI phase
Commercial Process:
- HIF budget of £15.6M as of 2019
- Construction works forecast cost £21.1M as of May 2021
- Savings promoted through the initial ECI phase
- But:
- Rising cost of materials and inflation
- Materials & labour shortage, supply chain increases
- Covid Pandemic
- Scheme costs would have been far higher without VE / ECI phase
Value Engineering: Practical Measures for Cost and Time Efficiency
Breheny’s value engineering strategy focused on identifying practical, cost-saving measures that also support long-term sustainability and efficient delivery. For earthworks, all fill material was sourced from a borrow pit located on land designated for future sports pitches, preserving development potential while reducing import costs. In drainage, the use of UPVC materials for sewers accelerated installation and reduced build time. Precast concrete elements, including manholes and culverts, further streamlined construction, while negotiations with the Environment Agency enabled the removal of free-span bridges, simplifying structural requirements. Bridge design was refined by reducing span and width, and incorporating weathering steel and integral bridge structures-both of which require minimal maintenance and eliminate the need for painting or bearings. Street infrastructure was also optimised by reducing the use of passively safe lighting equipment and avoiding unnecessary street furniture such as fencing and signage, contributing to a cleaner and more efficient urban environment.
Challenges & Solutions
- HIF Funding milestones – Supporting Hallam Land & Coventry CCin agreeing sensible dates.
- Targeting the HIF funding at the critical infrastructure to open upthe primary access.
- Fast tracked technical approval process via weekly meetings withCoventry City Council and Breheny.
- Phasing the works with Breheny to open up an access from thewestbound carriageway into the employment area / Phase 2.
- Rising cost of construction materials (steel / red diesel)
- Illumination of the highway works (to permit adoption) ahead ofthe primary sub station being energized
- Materials management strategy. Infill the borrow pit witharisings / topsoil to avoid exportation
Integrated Approach to Infrastructure Delivery: Breheny’s Collaborative Model
Breheny’s early involvement in the design phase of infrastructure projects has proven instrumental in enhancing construction feasibility and cost-effectiveness. By working closely with design teams from the outset, Breheny ensures that selected solutions are practical and economically sound, streamlining the transition from design to construction.
Strategic Design and Environmental Efficiency
Key examples of Breheny’s value-driven approach include the culverting of watercourses as an alternative to bridge construction, and early utilities and site investigations. These measures enable the use of site-won materials for earthworks, reducing environmental impact and promoting sustainability.
Quarrying, testing, and validating site-won aggregates for permanent works significantly reduce lorry movements on major roads such as the A45, lowering carbon emissions and minimizing disruption to local traffic.
Comprehensive Scope and Stakeholder Engagement
Breheny’s scope encompasses earthworks, drainage, road construction, structures, lighting, signage, attenuation ponds, and habitat creation. The company excels in managing interfaces with Coventry City Council, local businesses, and residents, ensuring smooth coordination and minimal disruption.
Co-location of client and delivery teams fosters real-time collaboration, while the programme is meticulously developed during tender and value engineering stages. Time risk allowances are built in for contractor-held risks, and constraints such as ecological factors and major events (e.g., the Commonwealth Games) are proactively considered.
Programme Management and Risk Mitigation
The construction programme is aligned with the pricing document activity schedule and serves as the basis for cashflow forecasting. It is baselined to track progress and is continuously updated to reflect real-time developments and delays.
Seasonal variations are accounted for in activity outputs, ensuring realistic scheduling and delivery expectations.
Technical Excellence and Sustainable Practices
Breheny addresses complex challenges such as utility diversions near critical structures, including large water service pipes and fibre optic cables. Temporary works are carefully designed to facilitate safe and efficient construction.
Surface water management is handled through innovative systems like new ditches and de-siltation processes. Collaboration with designers and suppliers ensures procurement of high-specification, bespoke materials tailored to project needs.
Meet Richard and Siobhan...
Richard Moorcroft
Read Profile
Siobhan Murphy
Read ProfileCheck out the Civils team...
Civil Engineering Group
More News
Why Foundation Strategy is a key for Infrastructure Delivery
April 3, 2026
Ground conditions remain one of the biggest sources of cost, carbon and programme risk in infrastructure delivery, yet foundation strategy is still too often considered too late. When layouts and levels are fixed before the ground is understood, projects lose the chance to shape efficient, predictable outcomes. This article explores why early, ground‑led design matters and how treating foundation strategy as a front‑end decision can unlock clarity, reduce risk and improve overall project performance.
Podcast Episode #14: The Housing Crisis, How Did We Get Here?
April 2, 2026
Explore how decades of UK housing policy, supply constraints, planning and affordability pressures created today’s housing crisis, and what lessons the past offers for future delivery.
Our March 2026 Newsletter
March 31, 2026
Welcome to our March 2026 newsletter. In this issue, we’ll tell you more about how we help SMEs prioritise what matters, avoid the common financial traps, and get projects moving, backed by our experienced team who have real housebuilding experience. We’re looking back on our March webinar, where Jack Kenny and Paul Rushmer gave an overview of how to optimise mechanical and electrical designs specifically for high-risk buildings. Plus, we’ll highlight this month’s podcasts! The first explored where structural engineering and building services design overlap, and why good coordination is so important to project delivery. In episode two, Hannah Simpson, Fran Walker, and Isabelle Latuszka spoke about their early-career experiences and how diverse backgrounds add real value to projects. Below, you’ll also get to hear about some exciting awards news and an event we’re co-hosting with the LPDF in Manchester.